Mr. Christmas Tree Pageant…and other Christmas Club Ideas

Drew Hill November 23, 2015

Below are tons of ideas to help make your Christmas Club a merry ol time. If you have other ideas to share, email us hereand we’ll add them to the post. 

Christmas Club Sample Schedule

We usually start club at 7:37, but for this particular event we start earlier to allow more time for the pageant. 

6:50-7:20- Pics with Santa/ Awkward Christmas Cards

7:20- Seniors form entry tunnel

7:22- Tonight, Yes, Tonight- Buddy the elf (host)

7:23- Christmas Medley (band)

7:26- 12 days of Christmas (mixer & song)

7:30- Mr. Christmas Tree Training Video

7:35- Mr. Tree group dance

7:40- Buddy the elf spaghetti game

7:44- Judges Panel introduced

7:45- Talent Competition

7:59- JibJab Elf head video

8:02- Announcements

8:04- Parade of Trees (Runway Script)

8:12- Contestant Interviews

8:16- Text Message Voting 

8:19- Joy To The World

8:23- What Child Is This?

8:26- Intro Drew

8:28- Drew’s Talk

8:43- Crown Mr. Christmas Tree

8:48-exit music

Mr. Christmas Tree Pageant 

Brian Summerall started doing ‘Mr. Christmas Tree’ at Pearce High School in Texas many years ago. You can read more about his vision for the pageant on his website. Since then, the idea has spread all over the country.  Many YL clubs have each grade nominate one guy to represent their class in the pageant.

When we started doing it 6 years ago, we decided to make it a senior guys competition. It’s created momentum and gave the underclassmen something to look forward to when they became seniors. This year’s senior guys will compete, many remembering their first ever MCTP they watched when they were freshmen. The last few years we’ve had around 15-20 senior guys compete. Each of them brings friends to club to ‘vote’ for them, so it typically is our highest attended club of the year.  Because of the energy surrounding the event, we also make it the first night folks can sign up for Crooked Creek, our summer camp trip.

*We also do a similar event, ‘The Ms. Valentines Pageant’ for the senior ladies in February.

Talent Competition

A fun way to get teachers, coaches, YL committee, and former YL leaders involved is to ask them to serve on the Judges Panel. 

If you select one guy from each grade, or use 4-8 total guys, each guy could have time to perform an individual talent like dancing, singing, silly tricks, etc… In that case the judges panel could use this sheet from Brian Summerall to help keep score.

If you have more than 8 guys, I’d recommend putting the guys into ‘talent groups.’ Last year we had 4 groups of 4 guys.

You can decide if the panel determines the winner, or if you vote by applause, text message, or by the audience each circling a name on a ballot you pass out towards the end of the competition.

12 Days of Christmas Skit

Here’s a funny skit idea for 2 of the contestants to do together while the rest of the contestants sing the 12 Days of Christmas. It feels a little long so I might just do it once starting on the 12th day. 


Parade of Trees

Summerall duct tapes actual trees to guys, which is hilarious. We encourage guys to dress as tree, open to their own interpretation. Some use actual tree branches taped to their body, some wear ornaments, tinsel, star hats, popcorn strings, some dress in green and brown, but every one of them is covered in strands of Christmas lights. After they walk down the runway onto the stage, we have a couple of power strips where they each can plug in their lights. (Some use battery packs)

During their runway walk we have an announcer reading a funny ‘runway script.’ Each guy submits personal stats they would put on a resume and we work together on making it funny. Here’s the script we used from a previous year. In the past I have asked the PA announcer at our high school football games to come in and read the script in his awesome football announcer voice.


We typically have someone dress up as ‘Buddy The Elf’ and host the entire evening as sort of a Ryan Seacrest/Will Ferrell combo character. It helps the flow of the evening if one person is directing stage traffic.


If possible, get last year’s Mr. Christmas Tree to return home for this club to crown the new winner. Create an elaborate ‘sash and star crown’ for the presentation. We’re doing this after the talk in order to give time to tally the votes during the talk, and it’s a fun way to conclude the evening.


If you have a handful of contestants, each guy should make their own ‘entry video’ or ‘training video.’ They could be practicing singing, doing pushups, running bleachers, visiting a Christmas tree lot, painting themselves green, duct taping branches on their bodies, drinking lots of egg nog, etc…

If you’re using a lot of contestants, make one training video together. Here’s the video we made a previous year:

Here are some examples of videos from other clubs:

Pearce Young Life

Pearce Young Life 2012

Wichata Falls Young Life 

Amarillo Young Life

Delta County Young Life


Ask friends for BIG inflatables and borrow Christmas lights. Click here for more details.


  • Rudolph, Feliz Navidad, and Jingle Bells are good fast ones.
  • ‘What Child is this?’ and ‘Silent Night’ are good slow ones.
  • Mariah Carey’s “All I want for Christmas is you” is good background music for fillers and games.
  • “Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays” by N’Sync is a must.


12 Days Of Christmas Song & Mixer  

As a mixer, use the song “12 days of Christmas” and divide your club into 6 groups. Group 1 will have “the 1st day of Christmas and the 7th day of Christmas, Group 2 will have day 2 and day 8, etc… Personalize the song to fit your club. Ex: If you took kids to Crooked Creek and the program team used Skippy the fish, then you could change the lyrics to: “On the first day of Christmas my true love gave to me, Skippy in a Crooked Creek.” Get creative.

Balloon Antlers

Get a few pairs of pantyhose and a bunch of balloons and have teams of 4 work together to blow up the balloons and then stuff them to see who can make the best reindeer antlers in 90 seconds. 


If you need a large group game you can play “Encore” or “Sing-off” and have each class compete (team of freshmen, team of sophs, etc…) to sing Christmas carols. If they repeat one that has already been sung, they are out. This works pretty well if you have team captains for each group.

Little Nemo Elf

The traditional “Little Nemo” skit works great with Elves. It’s explained here.  

Christmas Carols with Helium

Name that Christmas Carol

Buddy The Elf Spaghetti Contest

Start it off by showing the clip from the movie Elf whereWill Ferrell eats spaghetti with maple syrup, marshmallows, m&ms, & skittles. Then have a character come on stage dressed as an Elf. You can buy an “elf shirt” lots of places like Walmart/Target or online at Elf Shirt Purchase. Have “Buddy the Elf” come out with all the ingredients mentioned above. You also need a tarp, towels for the kids to clean up with afterwards, theme music to play in the background, and bowls. Have the kids race to eat with their hands. Give out decent sized portions where a kid can actually eat it all in a minute. If you put too much in there, it will take too long and be a dud.



Create a JibJab video of your YL leaders heads on the bodies of elves. You have to pay to download it, or you can just show it if you have internet where you have club.

Awkward Family Christmas Cards

Pics With Santa

Invite a committee member or parent to dress up as Santa and have kids get their pics taken with him. Invite another adult to take the pics in order to free up leaders to be with kids. Lighting is key for good photos. Chances are you have a parent or friend of YL in the community who loves photography, has a sweet camera, and would love to do it for free.

Candy Canes 

Pass them out before club. They’re cheap and festive.

Ugly Sweaters

Encourage kids to dress up in their ugliest Christmas sweaters. Odds are, their moms probably have some sweet ones in the attic. If not, a Goodwill trip is always great contact work.


Here are a few ideas thanks to Sean McGever and

Merry Christmas! -Drew Hill & The YLLB team

Join the Conversation

Sign up for our monthly email newsletter that keeps you updated with the most helpful and relevant content.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.